Leopoldstadt
Sep. 23rd, 2024 09:18 amLeopoldstadt, Tom Stoppard play at the Huntington Theatre (which seems to be going by The Huntington these days in their programs, perhaps to avoid the whole theater/theatre issue). I like Tom Stoppard, and I knew this would be heavy (it's about a Jewish family in Vienna in the first half of the 20th century, so you know how that's going to go) but I wanted to see what Stoppard would do with it. It's a very personal work - he's trying to imagine some of his own heritage and come to terms with his own family history - and it was powerful in exactly the way you'd expect. (While also sometimes pretty funny in the leadup, as Stoppard does.)
We had an interesting conversation afterwards about Holocaust art, about which I have many mixed feelings - in wanting to see this play, knowing it would be emotional and I would cry about it, is that, like, atrocity tourism of real historical suffering; does Holocaust art get used for justification of the modern state of Israel feeling they have infinite license to do supervillain shit you would normally spend two hours watching Batman or James Bond thwart (yes, I am talking about the pager attacks on Lebanon, which is not the only bad thing the state of Israel has done but is a recent and particularly shocking one); given that in the US one of our two major parties has high-office candidates who have called themselves Nazis or who are calling for the forcible deportation of 20 million people, do we conclude that Holocaust art is a failure at convincing people that holocausts are bad and we don't want any or would this shit be even worse if we weren't constantly turning off at least some potential fascists from fascism with timely application of Number the Stars or Maus or Diary of Anne Frank or Devil's Arithmetic or Schindler's List or or or. Probably nobody goes to see something like Leopoldstadt unless they're already anti antisemitism? Probably they are not going to generalize to "displacing and persecuting groups of people is bad in general" unless they already think that? I don't know.
We had an interesting conversation afterwards about Holocaust art, about which I have many mixed feelings - in wanting to see this play, knowing it would be emotional and I would cry about it, is that, like, atrocity tourism of real historical suffering; does Holocaust art get used for justification of the modern state of Israel feeling they have infinite license to do supervillain shit you would normally spend two hours watching Batman or James Bond thwart (yes, I am talking about the pager attacks on Lebanon, which is not the only bad thing the state of Israel has done but is a recent and particularly shocking one); given that in the US one of our two major parties has high-office candidates who have called themselves Nazis or who are calling for the forcible deportation of 20 million people, do we conclude that Holocaust art is a failure at convincing people that holocausts are bad and we don't want any or would this shit be even worse if we weren't constantly turning off at least some potential fascists from fascism with timely application of Number the Stars or Maus or Diary of Anne Frank or Devil's Arithmetic or Schindler's List or or or. Probably nobody goes to see something like Leopoldstadt unless they're already anti antisemitism? Probably they are not going to generalize to "displacing and persecuting groups of people is bad in general" unless they already think that? I don't know.